Operation: Dark Heart Unredacted

But the physical first edition? The one that didn't get pulped? That is a piece of history. It represents the tension between a soldier’s right to tell his story and a government’s duty to protect secrets. In the case of Operation Dark Heart , the redactions may have actually done the opposite of their intent: They didn't hide the story. They made sure everyone wanted to read it.

The book is a fascinating look at bureaucratic infighting, intelligence tradecraft, and the chaos of the early War on Terror. However, it became infamous not for what it said, but for what the government tried to stop. The standard procedure for a CIA or DIA officer publishing a memoir is "pre-publication review." Shaffer submitted his manuscript. The DIA reviewed it and cleared it. The book went to print—over 10,000 copies were already stored in a St. Paul, Minnesota, warehouse.

Using federal funds, the DoD purchased and pulped over 9,500 copies of the book. A second edition was quickly released. This is the version you can buy on Amazon today. It is heavily marked with black boxes. In some cases, entire pages are blacked out. The visible text refers vaguely to "sources and methods" that cannot be disclosed.